Wednesday, 29 February 2012

Review Ideas - Maribel


Just come across a review for Maribel - Reveries. Whilst the text shows room for creativity, this word cloud I've made shows that most of the key words are just band-related and aren't really about the music. An interesting turn this has shown is that if you cut out all of the background information, it doesn't leave the review with much to 'visualise.' It's more a biographical review and that takes away from the image potential and highlights how much some reviews rely on the text element of their message.

Without all of the key words related to the band (i.e. Maribel, Reveries, Record, Aesthetics (the name of their first release)) and all of the words needed structurally (i.e. 'although,' 'much' etc.) all there really is is 'dreamy, stensil, radiantly, haunting' and so forth, which are very vague terms and almost rely on the text for a context, as I also noticed 'danger' on there, and I believe the review references a lack thereof, rather than saying the record sounds 'dangerous.' With a review like this, I think it would be much more interesting to create some original artwork which depicts the tone and mood of the album rather than try to simply replicate certain quotes, which may have been the case with my M83 review.

I was considering using this review for my experiment, but I don't think it's written well enough from a creative perspective - but then again, my project is designed to highlight this, rather than rely on something that translates well. Whether it works as a medium of replacement is what I'm trying to discover; but on first glance, I would say this particular review won't have much resemblance to the original text.

Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Genre Diversity

I have had a change in plan for the experiment I posted a group for earlier: Now, I think I will assign each participant the latest reviews I can find in different genres - one in Alternative/Rock, one in Hip Hop, one in Pop, one in RnB or whatever, and I will make a corresponding image for each. So I will make 5, and each other person one each, if time permits. If they could each do two each, that would be great, so there is more variety, but I think so far, all of my pieces have been too similar from a genre perspective.

I will pick a reviews website - gravitating towards Pitchfork right now because some of their pieces can be quite controversial, and select the latest review in each genre so there is no favouritism and more of a random element. Hopefully no one would have heard the albums in question, so there will be no bias and each participant won't know what to expect. I might not even read each review myself until the links have been distributed. I think it's a better idea to include some diversity. By this time tomorrow, I would have started on my images at least. I will put together a rough sketch for a layout update before I see my tutor in the morning.

Whoops

I could not figure out for the life of me how to check results for the first survey I created, so I made a new one. The link is http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/2QFLJ68. There is an option to provide graphical reports on the results (which may be for premium members only) which could be nice. This survey takes up to 100 responses too, which is better.

Questionnaire


 As previously mentioned, I have just designed a short questionnaire to help with my research. It's only 5 questions long, but I was interested to see what people thought of the current state of music reviews and whether image-based reviews could have any impact on the industry. The survey will only take up to 50 results and lasts for 10 days, so hopefully I will get 50 of my Facebook friends to help me out. The results will just help to flesh out my research and could be included in future essays, if nothing else.

If any tutors reading this would like to help, the link is http://freeonlinesurveys.com/s.asp?sid=7hqio6h5n3jo24u10508 - thanks! Haha.

EDIT: Disregard the picture and the link to the survey - I couldn't log in to the website to check results! New one in next blog post.

Wheels Into Motion

Just created a group on Facebook for my experiment. Hopefully people will respond soon; my girlfriend, who excelled in art throughout her academic ventures, has also put herself forth to help. I will get a really interesting mix of graphical perspectives - myself taking a more collage-based approach, Nick, Josh and Kyle taking a more graphics-inspired outlook, and Eilish and Alex a more traditional artistic approach.

The response could be very interesting, paired with some of the reading I've been doing on language and linguistic interpretation (Barthes, as previously mentioned) and semiotics. Do reviews say the same things to everyone? Hopefully I will find out soon. I am about to create an online survey to advertise as well.

Sunday, 26 February 2012

The Death of the Author

Been reading up on Roland Barthes' 'Death of the Author.' Interesting quotes;
We know now that a text is not a line of words releasing a single 'theological' meaning (the 'message' of the Author-God) but a multi-dimensional space in which a variety of writings, none of them original, blend and clash. The text is a tissue of quotations drawn from the innumerable centres of culture. Similar to Bouvard and Pecuchet, those eternal copyists, at once sublime and comic and whose profound ridiculousness indicates precisely the truth of writing, the writer can only imitate a gesture that is always anterior, never original. His only power is to mix writings, to counter the ones with the others, in such a way as never to rest on any one of them. Did he wish to express himself, he ought at least to know that the inner 'thing' he thinks to 'translate' is itself only a ready-formed dictionary, its words only explainable through other words, and so on indefinitely
Really interesting stuff. So related to my project, the author of the review is not a 'voice of God,' dictating facts, according to Barthes. Instead they are merely compiling a variety of previous experiences in reading. And in turn, us as the reader is interpreting each text in relation to our previous experiences also. Barthes is questioning the need of the contemporary author, insisting that everything written these days is merely a reproduction of previous ideas. I could argue that my images do the same job, rendering both as essential (or non-essential) as the other. My original attempt at the project, in a way, was an aim to challenge language and linguistics, and the need for them. A lot of the readings I have done aren't really helping to guide me in a different direction. I think I need to look more into 'image interpration' and the legitimacy of indexical imagery. What makes Isotype, for example, as legitimate a source as it's perceived to be? Tomorrow's aim is to get Photoshop working and try to mock up a better draft of the 'gallery' incorporation.

Saturday, 25 February 2012

Frustration/Isotype Revisited

It's incredibly difficult finding resources on Google sometimes. Pages and pages of results from searches such as 'image translated to text' bring up articles about how Google can translate foreign text embedded within images. A library day is needed, for sure.

On another note, I have been browsing for critiques on Isotype (during which I found the transcript of a talk given by Michelle Henning at Reading University, interesting!) and came across this video. My German isn't great at all (practically nonexistant) but it's a nice insight into the creation of Isotype and some artists' own versions.



I'll post my reactions to certain images included etc. in the next update.