Tuesday, 13 December 2011

Research Report: Research

As a base for my project, I thought it was important to revisit my initial understanding of semiotics and intertextualisation. Initially I researched Daniel Chandler's thoughts on the boundaries imposed by audience understanding.

My main source of theoretical inspiration and research, in practice itself in regards to realising my project, was based around Edward Tufte's ideas of data visualisation. I am aware that Tufte is a renown practitioner of 'cognitive art' himself, but it is his reasoning and his theories that stand out to me. Tufte (1990: 9) believed that "To envision information (...) is to work at the intersection of image, word, number, art." Tufte's challenges of the boundaries and disregard for the limits are exactly what my research and the project itself is trying to highlight.

From this, I have tried looking into more music-based approaches and theories, and came across Juan C. Dürsteler's (2005) thoughts on music visualisation, which is a lot more based around literal visualisations of frequency spectrums and so forth. This was an interesting take on how to visualise music, as it takes away the sense of creativity in writing that I would be focussed on, and masks literal, matter of fact data in a visually pleasing way. Aside from this, there really does not seem to be much in the way of relating music and imagery. Hanna (2008) gives a brief insight into animated accompaniments to music over history, but aside from this there is a lot left to be desired.

In my design research, I looked into Otto Neurath's Isotype. I am yet to really develop the idea in the context of my own work, but the way Neurath tried reformatting written language into visuals using a "language-like technique" (2010) is something worth exploring, especially in a web based context. My current obstacle is how to go about illustrating each aspect of the data I retrieve, but I will look to further develop these ideas in the future.

To progress, I need to look more into music visualisation itself, and determine what the closest attempt to echo my idea has been so far, and from that, find out why. Tufte and websites like Information is Beautiful have brought up a lot of key points in my methodology, but relating it to music and researching the discourse around the link between music reviews as a text based format and music as audio is the next key area I need to research.

(408 words)

Research Report: Similar Work

In essence, websites such as 'Information is Beautiful' (http://www.information-is-beautiful.net) are trying to achieve what I am aiming for. To take something in its existing format, which in Information Is Beautiful's case is data collection, poll and survey results and so forth, and mine to take key elements of creative writing and present them in a way that is far more visual and arguably engaging for the viewer. This has influenced me in the way I am looking to approach my final piece, as I think it would be interesting to take some quantitative data from reviews and represent them in a different format, much in the way that Information Is Beautiful does.

I have searched extensively and have not found any websites who specialise in image-based music reviews, so a lot of the work that has inspired me has belonged to other fields which I can relate to my own. It is unclear to me whether this means that the idea is flawed, it may be seen as too gimmicky to actually work as a profit-drawing website, it may take too long to produce each review and cost too much, or anything else. Visually, in regards to the website, I was inspired by websites such as Los Angeles artist Mark Whalen (also known as Kill Pixie) who adopt a minimalist style. My interpretation was that I will let the images speak for themselves, and since my experiment is less about creating works of art, I am keen to avoid overshadowing the images with an overbearing website.

(256 words)

Research Report: Theoretical Context

My project examines the relationship between text and image, and what limitations there may be to that when trying to juxtapose the two beside each other, in an attempt to convey what is essentially the same message. The message I am trying to look into is whether or not visual imagery really works when trying to write about a non-visual thing - in my case, music reviews. In my understanding of the field, it seems to me that websites currently specialising in music reviews are not really making the most of what the medium of the web presents to them, and that is an unlimited palette for painting the visual picture they currently just present in written form, to accompany the music they are reviewing.

I am exploring themes such as intertextuality, semiotics and data visualisation, and am particularly interested in Edward Tufte's ideas that data should not be limited by its format. I feel personally that music reviews almost limit themselves by not at least exploring the idea of visual accompaniments, as so many writers seem to strive to make their interpretations a far more visual realisation. It usually comes down to the style of music and the skill of the writer when determining how well a review works as an image, so for that reason, Tufte's concepts become slightly alienated. It is not data in question here, it is a creative interpretation, and that provides problems. I feel that Tufte's theories can merely translate to a creative process, but his ideas articulate my own.

(256 words)

Sunday, 11 December 2011

Week 11

This week has been pretty much all about tightening everything up; adding images to blog posts I hadn't had a chance to format/upload, working on the website and making sure everything works (even though it is a bit basic at the moment) and generally rushing around to add more bulk to everything. About to finalise my proposal now.

Sunday, 4 December 2011

Week 10

I thought it would be interesting to cover an album by a band who don't really make music in the same vein as the other bands I have been covering with this project. The Black Keys are an American blues-driven garage rock band, who are much more straight and to the point than M83's dreamy soundscapes, for example. The difference in my image speaks for itself really, with the writer comparing The Black Keys to a lot of other artists rather than painting a visual picture of how the music sounds. This, comparatively with images like the M83 one, really highlight what it is I'm looking into here; how language and imagery relate, and whether or not it works in helping the audience to know what to expect. The following image was just kind of done on a whim, so it's far from finished, but already you can see that it's a lot more matter-of-fact, a lot more 'this is what happened when the record was made, this is who it sounds like' rather than being too visually descriptive.



7/10 It feels pretty strange to be typing these words, but of late The Black Keys have undoubtedly become something of a big deal. Their last album ‘Brothers’ scooped three Grammy awards (Best Alternative Album, Best Rock Performance and Best Recording Package, whatever that is) and sold over a million copies worldwide. They recently announced a second show at London’s 10,000-capacity Alexandra Palace after the first sold out in under a week.

How did these jobbing blues-rockers from Akron, Ohio, suddenly get so huge? One persuasive theory is that they’ve merely inherited 'The White Stripes’ fanbase, with Jack and Meg’s demise creating a vacuum in the world of rootsy guitar-and-drums duos that the nominally similar Black Keys have rushed in to fill. In fact, they’ve outlasted almost all of the other bands who rose to prominence during the garage rock revival a decade ago (whither now the likes of The Datsuns and The Von Bondies?) and simply by being the last men standing in the vicinity of a vintage Fender Twin, The Black Keys have cleaned up.

But that’s only half the story. Over the last few albums, with the aid of regular producer Danger Mouse, The Black Keys have been gradually evolving from bluesy bar-band scufflers into streamlined rock ravagers. ‘El Camino’ had to be a record that justified the band’s elevation to the arena circuit, and it comes up trumps with a fat-free set of thumping uptempo rockers and primitive soul stompers.

Whereas previously the pair would never discuss tactics before entering the studio to jam, here every song sounds purposeful and premeditated. Single and opener ‘Lonely Boy’ sets the tone with its rabble-rousing rockabilly rumble. Even for committed minimalists like The Black Keys, the song is brutally simple, with Dan Auerbach refusing to wait for a reciprocal glance before yanking his heart out and slapping it on the table (“I don’t mind bleeding” he sings, blithely). ‘Run Right Back’ borrows its sleazy strut from Queens Of The Stone Age’s ‘No One Knows’, succinctly sketching out another fatal attraction scenario (“Finest exterior/ She’s so superior/ But she won’t allow/And I’m wounded now”) to a rhythm that feels like a finger jabbing in your chest. ‘Little Black Submarines’ is more ambitious, starting out in Johnny Cash territory before exploding into a psycho-blues freakdown.

‘Sister’, with its insistent ’80s pulse, is simply the best out-and-out pop song they’ve ever written, while the brilliantly demented cowboy glam holler of ‘Gold On The Ceiling’ is boosted by the band’s new trio of female backing singers wailing for all they’re worth. It’s a lot of fun, although The Black Keys have (presumably unwittingly) just rewritten Super Furry Animals’ demented cowboy glam holler ‘Golden Retriever’. ‘Money Maker’ also sounds comfortingly familiar, with a primary riff that’s a ringer for The Hives’ ‘Main Offender’ (although that’s OK, because it’s not like The Hives are around to play it for themselves).

Ultimately, when you’re working with such basic, well-worn materials, none of it is going to sound particularly original, but ‘El Camino’ is at least thrusting and urgent and very quickly to the point. Whatever Danger Mouse has done to galvanise The Black Keys – and thankfully he’s left his trademark soporific shuffling drums at home, the Keys’ Pat Carney being more of a bare-knuckle bludgeoner – he’s got the band operating at maximum efficiency.
The Black Keys will never really be able to boast the fizzing sexual tension and weirdo intrigue of The White Stripes, the dazzling dexterity of White Denim, nor the strutting showmanship of The Jon Spencer Blues Explosion, The Make-Up or The Hives. But for 37 rollicking minutes, they give it the full gun, meeting the challenge of being the biggest garage rock band in the world head-on.

Sam Richards

Friday, 25 November 2011

Week 9

I've spent some time cleaning up my blog last night and today; with each week that passed, I created a blank draft, ready for the entries, so I have been filling in where I'd missed, and actually publishing everything. I have written notes scribbled in my jotter, and wrote down key ideas before expanding, so I've been typing everything up. It's my birthday in two days and there are some problems at home that I need to go back and help with; family illness and so on, so I may not make it in next week, but obviously I will still be developing my ideas and looking into further reading.

Sunday, 20 November 2011

Week 8

This week I have been conducting further theoretical and methodological research. In my initial discussions in the tutorials about placing my work into a theoretical context, a number of key figures were brought to my attention, and I had only just realised that I'd saved quite a few bookmarks on the UWE system. So without further adieu;



Otto Neurath. (1882-1945) An Austrian social scientist, political economist and philosopher.

Neurath designed Isotype, which is  the International System of Typographic Picture Education. Isotype is basically a system implemented to put data visualisation into practice. Isotype is simply a method of displaying information gathered from data in a text format. Neurath teamed up with Gerd Arntz in order to actually create the language. Antz designed upwards of 4000 images to correspond with Neurath's ideas, and focussed around industrial and political ideas when approaching the design. It was significant at the time of design, around 1935, because the majority of those working in the industry could not read or write, let alone deal with industry terminology, so the idea was to create a simple way of understanding.


Gerd Antz's website brings forth the idea that 'Another outspoken goal of this method of visual statistics was to overcome barriers of language and culture, and to be universally understood.' I believe this ties in well with my approach to the project, but at the same time, depending on the review, a certain amount of intertextual awareness and, I suppose, a sense of cultural capital will help the reader to understand the images easier. A lot of reviews feed off of the audience's awareness of similar-sounding artists and so on, which could be a barrier when perhaps more interesting ideas, in a similar vein to Isotype, is introduced.

It would be interesting for me to create my own form of Isotype specifically for my website. Since I am not particularly artistically gifted when it comes to hand drawing, it may be something to explore in the second half of the semester. If I get a chance, I will attempt to create something as an experiment though. But for now, it doesn't really work as a critique on whether or not text based reviews are successful, it merely collects the data in a more visually pleasing way.